DISQUS

AMERICAblog: Are Barney Frank, Tammy Baldwin, Howard Dean and Jared Polis really going to honor Biden at a gay DNC fundraiser this month?

  • V. M. · 6 months ago
    Sorry, but after reading I definitely feel compelled to put in my two sense. I'm not gay but live in NY and am pretty much numb to anything you can throw at me (aka - ok a bit more on the liberal than conservative side, probably just my age) and I definitely believe in live and let live. However, that being said, there's a few things that the gay community can and should do if they want want their fight to end on a successful note sooner rather then later, and I say this because I know your struggle will eventually prevail because of the kind-hearted, good-nature and general good moral compass of the average American citizen. The commenter "This Bears Repeating" made some of the points I would like to reiterate, whereas people need to see a fight in order to stop and stare and pay attention. Without that, your cause just won't seem worthy enough. The average person needs to see or experience your struggle in order to empathize. Second, entice a powerful politician to help you gain ground. Nothing like a little quid pro quo where it belongs to get the ball rolling. Or prop one up, so that he has no power without you. And make sure that he or she is beholden to your cause this time! Third, MARRIAGE is a RELIGIOUS institution. Your are essentially fighting the GOVERNMENT and the CHURCH (POWER!), who have been joined at the hip for millenia, at the same time! Who knows, the government may be secretly fighting for the church on this one so they don't have to get their hands dirty while they try to clean up in-house. Does it really need to be called marriage? Once you've got those numbers crunched, study that legal brief along with DOMA until you have a productive counter-argument for EVERY bullet-point. Lastly, this fight should in every way equate with the civil-rights fight (which was won so may be used as a blueprint), so draw direct comparisons. And remember this in the future. Only fools trust in politicians and lawyers. A man is but a man. Sorry if you thought otherwise. The struggle continues. Much luck and success.
  • Chris · 6 months ago
    There's two things you need to be careful of John. One, this is NOT the WH's political position. This is the DOJ defending the laws of the land. Remember? Justice is a seperate entity from the WH. Two, the one thing you can ding Obama/Biden on would be not jumping in and letting the law go undefended, that's something you can do. That's basically the only thing.

    DOJ still has a lot of Bushies as political appointees, in fact that's probably the case here.
  • Houndentenor · 6 months ago
    If that is the case, the administration needs to make that argument themselves and by the end of the day. Damage control is needed. Sorry but this is part of the administration, not an independent branch of the government.
  • RainbowPhoenix · 6 months ago
    The buck stops where?
  • Randy · 6 months ago
    The WH could have easily made a phone call to the attorneys and told the to go easy on the brief. Heck, Obama has a cabinet meeting each week where he sees the AG.

    In fact, that should be gov't wide policy by now -- gays are to be treated at EVERY LEVEL of gov't as full and equal citizens. If you don't get it, then resign from your position.

    It's really not that hard to set policy like this. Cheney held everyone's feet to promote his interests for eight years, and I don't think he wasted any time at all once he got in office.
  • NRafter530 · 6 months ago
    That wouldn't be policizing the Justice Department?
  • NRafter530 · 6 months ago
    With the American people who have voted to ban marriage equality in every state where it was put on the ballot.
  • nicho · 6 months ago
    Are you saying that Obama isn't in control of his administration? Are you saying that he is just a figurehead and that there are rogue elements running the departments? That's only making things worse.
  • NRafter530 · 6 months ago
    We if he is in control of the Justice Department on stuff like this, then he's breaking the law and deserves to be impeached.

    Or was that only when Bush did it?
  • greensburg · 6 months ago
    I received a "2009 Priority Issues Survey" from the Democratic Headquarters last week. I was not very nice with what I had to say since equal rights were not mentioned anywhere at all. I filled it out and put equal rights in each section then in the comments section told them no money and no votes until I see postive ACTION from the dems on my rights. After today, I wish I had waited another week to fill it out because it would have been a lot nastier. The gay community and its "defenders" (ie: HRC Lambda Legal, et al) need to strongly condem what this administration is doing (or not doing) or they will loose all my financial support. I can't wait to run into the HRC people at the Louisville Pride fesitval in a week (I will be there for business). They lost my $ a while ago but some of the other ones I still hand over my money to, but now I will be very diligent.
  • Indigo · 6 months ago
    You've been too easy on the DNC. I got a last-chance letter from them recently for failure to donate within the past year. Bwa-ha-ha-ha-ha!
  • Jophus · 6 months ago
    John, are todays posts what you sent the bat signal to Rachel the other day? I hope you got a bunch of people organized.
  • Trev · 6 months ago
    Good for you, John. And please don't listen to the people who say you're being too 'uppity.'

    There's little to be gained by blind faith, passivity and wagging our tails every time Obama tosses a bone.
  • Clint · 6 months ago
    So, who ARE we going to give our money to, if not the Democrats? I'm not a huge fan of the party right now, but still...any ideas? Any electable ideas? How about all those Democrats who DO support absolutely equality for LGBT folks?
  • Randy · 6 months ago
    Hold on to your money for now. We will need it if there is a ballot measure to repeal SSM in Maine and to repeal recognition of other states SSM in WAshington, DC. There is talk about another ballot initiative in CA to repeal Prop 8.

    So there are plenty of battle ahead. Save your money for where it counts, and make sure that you let the Dems know why you are spending your money there and not with them
  • nicho · 6 months ago
    My money is being saved for repeal of Prop H8 and for AIDS causes, since Arnold is going to starve them of fund in CA.
  • Eric · 6 months ago
    I decided not give to party apparatus groups like the DNC and instead give directly to good candidates.
  • RichardS · 6 months ago
    I thought George W lost the election?? Guess I was wrong! Yet another Obama disappointment! They say look at all the money they'll save by not recognizing gay marriage......... well, we gays should say back to them... look at all the money we'll save by no longer giving to the Democrat party.
  • Al · 6 months ago
    John-

    Why don't you get out those Monica Lewinsky stamps that you used during the campaigns! You made your bed. Thank yourself for this.
  • Randy · 6 months ago
    So they are honoring Biden for what? Paying lip service to the community? Making mighty promises? Showing up for a chicken dinner? Having a gay friend?

    I guess that's all you need to be 'honored' by the gay establishment nowadays. "He likes us, he really likes us!" That he doesn't do crap to repeal DADT or DOMA doesn't mean a damn thing to these so-called leaders. They ought to be shamed.

    If they had any balls, they would withdraw the invitation to Biden and tell him that when he or Obama make a major push or at least a major speech (the bully pulpit Obama promised us), only then does he get reinvited.
  • TrappedinaRedState · 6 months ago
    Let him show... and let him experience first hand the wrath of people who have been thrown under his administration's bus.

    Consider it a learning experience - it might do him some good.
  • Butch1 · 6 months ago
    I would hope that, in light of the most recent events, they would cancel this event and have it at a later time or choose some gay luminary to be the guest of honour.
  • FNReedie · 6 months ago
    Not another dime to the DNC, Obama, or any other candidate that does nothing more than talk. Period. You want my support, you prove it ... Obama screwed the LGBT community, sided with Wall Street, and seems to be crumbling on healthcare.
  • Buzzcook · 6 months ago
    I don't see any reason not to hold Biden's feet to the fire. But it is Obama's justice department, they are his lawyers arguing the case. In the end it is Obama that is responsible for the actions of his administration.

    Maybe Obama could shift Clinton to Justice from State. We need an AG with some balls.
  • lynchie · 6 months ago
    John: please do not continue to suggest that Biden not attend. That is exactly what he should do and he should hear first hand how back stabbing the Gay community after getting their support and money will have consequences. For any one who thinks the DOJ is separate from the WH you are nuts. Not a single thing should be done without the WH's approval. If the lawyers there want autonomy go get a job in the private sector chasing ambulances.
  • Jophus · 6 months ago
    That is a really good point. He should have to go and face humiliation.
  • bucklerjc · 6 months ago
    Don't bother calling the phone number listed on the invite----it just goes to voice mail. Guess they don't want to talk to the gay community-----just want our money.
  • dancob · 6 months ago
    John, you're just not understanding the Obama calculus on this issue! Look, seeing angry gays protesting Biden will make the 2012 Obama/Biden ticket more palletable to the "right-of-center-voters" in Indiana, Ohio, Michigan, Nevada, even Texas... and really, where are the gays going to go in the 2012 election. Obama will publicly continue to throw gays under the bus whenever and wherever he can to prove his "mainstream" bona fides. That's what this is all about. The DOJ brief filed in court today could very well have been the fodder intended to incite a gay response at the Biden event. Remember, Obama KNOWS he's got to get a certain percentage of middle-of-the-road voters in the next election. Crapping on gays will get their attention and possibly their support.
    THAT'S the calculus....! And the moral to be learned from this story is: Do not trust anything Obama says about gay issues. They've already completely backtracked on DADT.
  • Cal · 6 months ago
    That calculus only holds if you say motivated grassroots supporters that are free with time and donations are...well..worthless.I know this gay person left the dems behind and went to the greens for two cycles in a row...and dont forget that 500 vote loss in Fla. This same gay person was very active with time and money in the last cycle. You say that gays have nowhere else to go, that is probably true in the larger sense, but if they don't show up at the party it will make a difference and it has in the past.
  • Luke · 6 months ago
    Marriage is the joining of one man and one woman. Period. Anything else is immoral, illogical, and a detrement to society. God help us all if gays are allowed to marry against the will of the people. Gays can do what they want in their own homes, but don't force me or my country to recognize them as married ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Toldyaso · 6 months ago
    "Is honesty and integrity no longer a core value in the Obama administration?

    What made you think it was EVER a value of ANY kind in this administration? Did you bother to check out this guy's sordid history and crazy beliefs before voting for him? How about those critically acclaimed "autobiographies" he didn't write (but shamelessly takes credit for), all those dubious stories and anecdotes, all those "because blah blah . . . therefore, here I am blah blah" speeches in which the first parts and the last parts never connect by any logic whatsoever? His ability to weave tales and hypnotize the gullible puts every president before him to shame, while the public's willingness to be tricked puts the entire species to shame. When a presidential candidate has an official LOGO for christsake (which he's STILL using) and a FAKE presidential seal, it's a fair bet you're dealing with a maniac and windbag of the first order. And what about ALL those photos with "accidental" halos around or behind his head, the Obama votive candles, the cruciform and transfiguration artworks?

    As a gay person, I learned to recognize charlatans pretty early on, but it seems that millions of gay people have been royally hoodwinked, supporting a candidate who secretly looks down on them (except for his wife's makeup artists and stylists), and who would say anything for a vote or a positive magazine cover. Now all that needs to happen to close the traditional gaybasher's circuit is for him to turn out to be gay himself.

    Next time, vote for the humble candidate, not the one seeking adoration, and forget selfish interests, because you only get what you pay for.
  • Janice · 6 months ago
    I understand your anger. Be very careful with the angle of attack below though: I believe that you may stretch your credibility with it and alienate some of the traditional allies you will need in the future.

    Again, Obama seems to states have the right to ban blacks from marrying whites:

    [T]he public policy doctrine, which has long recognized the sovereign authority of the States to decline to give effect to the laws of a sister State at variance with their own legitimate public policy. Section 2 of DOMA merely confirms the specific applicability of that longstanding principle in the context of laws regarding same-sex marriage.
  • Mud Worm · 6 months ago
    If Obama says DOMA is fair then it is fair. Who are you to question him!
  • Ron Paul · 6 months ago
    Vote Libertarian!! Equal rights for all!
  • Emma · 6 months ago
    Let's all be gay, resort to artificial insemination to have kids, with many girls brought up by 2 men and many boys by 2 women so that they can never identify with a parent of the same sex and fail to grow up as they should, or become gay in turn. Or maybe we won't have kids anymore, this way the human race can end sooner. Let's concentrate on sex and avoid love at all cost. After all, aren't we free beings here to do whatever we please?
    Well the answer is NO. You think freedom is anarchy, for bit of sex or money. Equality you say? Same rights? And why do you always assume that everybody is entitled to what they want, like a bunch of kids demanding anything they want now now now. No one gets their ways entirely. What kind of a society would a gay society be? Do you even think about it? No, you don't. You want what you want and that's that. Some people have no freedom at all, not even that of expressing themselves or going out. Some people love each other completely without ever being able to be together. Enough with gay rights. Time to play it low. We don't need our kids to be influenced by you, like fashion, like smoking, just to try, you know...A gay world = the end of the human race. I haven't met any gay person who didn't suffer from psychological trauma in childhood. In my 20s, I used to support gays because I didn't think of the consequences, I didn't understand the difference between freedom and anarchy, nor was the difference between love and sex so clear. 20 years later and after having heard several gay people telling me their stories, my opinion has changed a lot. Live your lives as you can, but society needs you to keep a low profile. Don't expect to be granted the same rights as a heterosexual couple, why should you be? What good contribution to society do you have to offer through being gay, what future for our kids?
  • Clint · 6 months ago
    LGBT folk are a very small minority, and are so not by choice but by nature, as has been proven time and time again. Such a post as the above has no basis in empirical facts or rationality, neither compassion nor empathy, but totally in self-serving appeals to personal distaste and authority as primary bases of morality. This will never be a "gay world", and gay folk do not want it so, but gay folk are a part of the world as it is. Most gay folk I know have not suffered childhood trauma any more than straight people, except those traumas suffered at the hands and mouths of adults like Emma who emotionally torture and scar their LGBT children as soon as the evidence begins to present itself.

    It is inevitable that people who want the whole world to be just like them, who want the whole world to look and act and believe just as they do, would expect the rest of the world to want the same, and see the world through conflicted-tainted glasses. Gay people do NOT want the whole world to be just like them, they want everyone to be exactly who they are, and to be honored for that. It is inconceivable to Emma and her ilk that the world can be full of many different beliefs and ways of life that can live together and learn from each other without person A always trying to convince person B of person B's errant, even sinful ways, and of person A's cultural, religious and maybe even racial superiority.

    Well I'm sorry Emma, you are on the losing side of pretty much everything, and wrong about most all of it. I could care less if you are morally wrong, which I believe you to be, but you are definitely empirically wrong about the basic facts of existence concerning genetics, sexuality, child-raising, etc. When people are killed, either at their own hands or at the hands of others because of what you and your kind are saying; when lives are ruined beginning at childhood; when people cry themselves to sleep for an infinite amount of reasons because of the beliefs you are spouting, then I hope grace pours upon you, because if it doesn't, the ravages of time, karma and whatever truly merciful god there might be will hold you accountable, and find you entirely at fault.
  • rick W · 6 months ago
    Gee..and to think that you got married without even asking my permission? Heres a hint Emma, I spent most of my 45 years on this planet trying to placate people like you and it got me nothing in return but your snide superior attitude. I may be gay but you dont have a clue what my morals are or are not. You have no idea what does or does not happen in my bedroom. And the bottom line is who really gives a cr*p what your opinion is about MY life? It's really none of your business, and the last thing I need is your know it all approval to make it complete. So butt out Emma and devote yourself to making your own family miserable cuz I pity any kids that would have to live with a mom like you. Meanwhile I pursue equal justice under the LAW.
  • Skott · 6 months ago
    Emma, Emma, Emma . . . Does the word "rational" mean anything to you?
  • Dave · 6 months ago
    It seems that Obama has not proved to be the Messiah that many hoped and fantasized about. Instead, a number of socialist ideological putsch are rapidly being enacted. If the brown shirts come out next, I wonder how many will really be surprised? After all, we already have had a number of czars named.
  • alabama · 6 months ago
    gay marriage shouldnt exist, homosexuality is insane. you cant have sex with a horse and then claim you were born that way. and i think it is awsome we dont have to listen to more crazy people try to convince us to respect them as a certain group of people. you cant pretend to be something and demand respect. and it is sad when most of the countries in the world look at america and laugh because we have so many gay people, we have gay people for the same reason we have little kids going to school dressed in all black trench coats and shooting people. people in general have lost the concept of family and community, men dont know how to be men, because it is women raising them, or it is women telling them how to be men. women dont know how to be women because all they see on TV is how men just want sex, and women should be able to do everything men do. everyone for the last 40 years has just argued and tried to destroy what social order we had to change thing, but they didnt just change one or 2 things, they tried to destroy everything. freedom means everyone gets to chose thier own way in life, but we are still human, a man is still a man, you cant change reality. homosexuals are usually very intense people who are tring to define themselves as something...its like a rapper telling me to keep it real....really you have to wear pants down to you knees? its not really how you wear them. are you keeping it real, or just putting on a show.
  • Jay · 6 months ago
    When it's all over this current administration will go down as one of the most corrupt administrations in U.S. History, and not entirely the fault of BHO either. He unfortunately has surrounded himself with selfish radicals with huge chips on their shoulders, all wanting to "get theirs" now. I actually feel kinda sorry for him!
  • alabama · 6 months ago
    i dont want to have to think about another man tring to kill me and eat me, and i dont want to think of him tring to have sex with me. why do we have to listen to people make things up and try to force us to accept them as reality, it is physically possable to eat another human....in a scocity where i dont know my place from one person to the next. are we are supose to destroy scocity so a few people get to chose thier own reality? gay people are mentally insane, that is reality.
  • Fox · 6 months ago
    Son, what the FUCK are you talking about.
  • Charlotte · 6 months ago
    Scocity? Is that some kind of scrotum joke I'm not getting? Alabama, I truly fear people who think like you. The thought that you think about serial killing is pretty disturbing. If you are truly scared about thinking about another man and yourself having sex, well, maybe you have some issues you need to work through. See, people who are comfortable with their sexuality don't think like you do. Go see a doctor. You seriously need some help. Also, go back to school so you can learn how to spell.
  • Rick · 6 months ago
    Biden is part of the Obama's administration which has just made it official in court filing Obama’s unbridled condemnation of LGBT community. If Biden shows up, he will represent Obama’s hatred and bigotry. Obama should ask National Organization for Marriage, Pat Robson and Tony Perkins to host his fund raiser!
  • Bill · 6 months ago
    Whew...Alabama....I wouldn't get within 20 feet of your ignorant, rotting corpse, much less eat it. With a mind....and I use the term losely.... like yours, I'm more afraid for the people of Alabama than I am for us gay people. Do you have a serial killer fetish?
  • Donald Hitchcock · 6 months ago
    I think the Dallas Principles are relevant here. Particularly Numbers 1, 3, 5, 7, and 8.

    The following eight guiding principles underlie our call to action.
    In order to achieve full civil rights now, we avow:
    1.Full civil rights for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender individuals must be enacted now. Delay and excuses are no longer acceptable.
    2.We will not leave any part of our community behind.
    3.Separate is never equal.
    4.Religious beliefs are not a basis upon which to affirm or deny civil rights.
    5.The establishment and guardianship of full civil rights is a non-partisan issue.
    6.Individual involvement and grassroots action are paramount to success and must be encouraged.
    7.Success is measured by the civil rights we all achieve, not by words, access or money raised.
    8.Those who seek our support are expected to commit to these principles.

    www.thedallasprinciples.org
  • Noel Siksai · 6 months ago
    Unfortunately, most of the GLBT organizations like HRC have active, day to day working links with the DNC, the White House, and the Congressional leadership. They'll be there in droves just to be able to fawn and say "we have access now." Frankly I think we as a community need to indulge in some overdue ass-whoopings for our so-called leadership.
  • Snowman · 6 months ago
    I surely wouldn't pay 1,000 to do do it, but I sure would like a chance to go face to face with Biden.

    In reality, LGBT people need to tell the Democratic machine to F*(# off for now. When the party has actually ACHIEVED something on LGBT rights, then we'll talk.

    Support the state Dems in places like HN, Maine, and your home state if they are actually taking corageuous stands. tell the national Democratic party to suck a lemon until they get Obama back on track for our rights.

    John Marty in Minnesota is a Democrat I can be proud of - and he's running for Governor after lead-authoring a bill this year that would pave the way to marriage equality. That's a man that understands the fierce urgency of our fight.
  • Ronald M · 6 months ago
    An open letter to:
    The Democratic Party LGBT Leadership Council
    Brian Bond
    Executive Director
    gllc@dnc.org

    Thomas Petrillo
    Finance Director
    PetrilloT@dnc.org


    Dear Mr. Bond and Mr Petrillo,


    The following is a letter to Barney Frank and Tammy Baldwin. It will be snail mailed to them. You and they need to know that it is being sent to our mailing list and I am encouraging those on the list to forward it to every one they know.

    The Obama administration has declared war on our community. We obviously have zero influence on this administration. We need to stop financing our own oppressors.


    To Representatives:

    Barney Frank
    Tammy Baldwin
    2446 Rayburn Building

    Washington DC, 20515


    June 16th.

    Today is our Anniversary. We have been together 39 years. We are discriminated against at every turn by the federal government. The administration has declared war on our community. We need to stop financing our own oppressors.

    We are consistent if small donors to your political career. It is time for action not just platitudes.

    Why would we want to give you another cent if you attend the dinner for Joe Biden, after the administration’s insulting and vicious attack on us? We will encourage every person we know, LGBT and our allies, to stop supporting those who give approval to our oppressors.

    It is time for our leaders and community to show some backbone. We will be watching your actions.

    Furiously,

    Ronald M and Richard D