DISQUS

AMERICAblog: Mom kills son, then self at shooting range

  • benb · 8 months ago
    At the very least can't this country demand that every gun carry insurance?
  • cowboyneok · 8 months ago
    "I'm so sorry," Marie Moore wrote several times. "I had to send my son to heaven and myself to Hell."

    What a typical wingnut Talibangelical idea! She thinks she determines who goes where after death. Wonder what Talibangelical church she goes to?
  • An_American_Karol · 8 months ago
    Isn't Florida like Texas where there's a church on every corner? Here in California we have "Stop and Go's" within a short stroll from every house.
  • cowboyneok · 8 months ago
    Just finished reading the article, and she was mentally ill - BIG TIME. No business whatsoever having a gun in her hands and her family should have known that with her history. Of course, she didn't think she was crazy, but its obvious her family knew of her mental health history.
  • erick · 8 months ago
    well i think she wrote that because in her mind as derranged as it was she thought taking a life send you to hell but in the opposite if your life is being taken then you are granted heaven or something.
  • True Bob · 8 months ago
    The first version of this story that I saw said the other patrons ran when the shooting started. So having armed citizens will prevent gun-toting maniacs, since those citizens, with guns drawn and ready to shoot, will...run away?
  • cowboyneok · 8 months ago
    Having bb guns is supposed to protect us from our government. Chortle... As if. Maybe back before the government discovered weapons that mostly make militias owning guns irrelevent. The right needs to just get used to the fact the government will never take their guns because the government knows if it ever came down to a "war" against them, it would be a joke how quickly the government would "win." I'd like to see them try to aim and fire their guns after they had their ear drums blown out with sound waves and then melted with directional micro waves from tanks, and I'm not even gonna start on biologics and blister agents. I'm just saying, the whole "gotta protect my freedom with my gun" has outlived its usefulness.
  • True Bob · 8 months ago
    I totally agree, and have argued same with some 2nd Amendment kooks. Even if you barricade yourself in, after they take you out, you are reported as a lone gun kook. The level of weaponry in even an organized militia pales next to a mere handful of military attack vehicles.
  • cowboyneok · 8 months ago
    Yep... agree.
  • cowboyneok · 8 months ago
    The video is very disturbing. It doesn't show the actual shooting but the Mom aiming the gun at her son's head.
  • Shochu John · 8 months ago
    I don't see this as about gun control at all. There are no fewer than a thousand ways a mother could kill her son: Poisoning, stabbing, electrocution. I also don't see how you figure out who the nutbars are ex ante.

    This sort of thing is not at all crazy, but is instead incredibly logical, if you start from the premise that there are a heaven and hell and good people go to the former and bad people to the latter. Mothers want the best for their children. Heaven is the best. It all follows pretty clearly. So, why won't people say the obvious? The problem is religion.
  • Butch1 · 8 months ago
    As an atheist, I look at this as a person deciding the fate of another with delusional thinking of an heaven or an hell as a consequence. I wonder if this person's decision would have been different if she were a non-believer? I think people who believe this deeply have a psychological neurosis impeding their ability to make logical decisions. Yes, the problem is religion.
  • TomJoad · 8 months ago
    All those methods are less easy. Less readily avaliable. Poison, over time, or worry about pain in death. Stabbing...lots harder to do very personal very nasty and may not do it quickly, electrocution not certain at all...circuit breakers ground fault.

    The fact you are trying to gloss over is, pulling a trigger is instantanous (so you don't have time to change your mind...) relative to other methods easier, can be done at larger distances, and is "the accepted" method. lots of tradition here.

    People that have been felons in most states can't vote after that. But they can own guns. We live in the society we deserve.
  • Brad · 8 months ago
    Scary, that religionist stuff.
  • HereinDC · 8 months ago
    I have to tell ya....

    I can't get over how amazing YouTube is.

    The more you hear and see things like this...the more it makes bible thumpers look like loons.
  • Ginger_FL · 8 months ago
    make sure you watch all the "Jesus camp" videos....
    OMG....My son searched for them since he went with a girl very briefly last year that wanted to "fix him". She had attended "jesus camp" and wanted my son to go.
    My son has been raised by Heathen athiests so he has been able to form his own opinions and think for himself.
    He has NO interest in organized religion of any kind...neither does my Heathen actor daughter.

    Pats self on back... ;D ;D
  • beingqreus · 8 months ago
    as a mom of 2 young twenties, I can relate. My kids dealt with the peer pressure from their religious fundie peers all through school. My daughter decided to switch to a different high school her freshman year to get away from it. My son toughed it out, but it wasn't easy.
  • RobertSeattle · 8 months ago
    Speechless. We need a way for people who need help to get help without the possibility of humuliation
  • MNPundit · 8 months ago
    Huh? You don't see it, all you see is her pointing the gun at him. Did they not release the actual shooting part?
  • cowboyneok · 8 months ago
    "MOM! What did you just DO?!!?"

    "I'm sorry, son, I thought I was sending you to heaven and me to hell."

    "Next... Okay, well, well, well, Marie, YOU really learned a lot in this reincarnation! Lets see... now what to do here... What are we gonna be this time around?"

    Marie, "Doh!"

    LOL!
  • RainbowPhoenix · 8 months ago
    Well that was tasteless.
  • cowboyneok · 8 months ago
    You are right, Rainbow. I removed it. After reading the article, I should have immediately removed it. This lady was insane. Its nothing to joke about.

    I'm sincerely sorry. I was trying to be funny, but "reincarnation vs. Christianity humor" wasn't appropriate in this context at all. It WAS tasteless, and I apologize again.
  • Older_Wiser · 8 months ago
    Religion and violence go hand in hand.

    I just read about a 77 yr old Indiana woman who was killed trying to break up a sword fight (!) between her 39 yr old son and 69 yr old brother in law.

    Frankly, I would have let them finish each other off and stayed out of it.
  • Rich · 8 months ago
    this seems pretty typical for the South, except it's usually a male and he typically takes out his wife/ex-wife/girlfriend, along with one or more children and possibly a mother-in-law. In some ways, she is a walking poster child for better gun licensure; however, it's really difficult to predict dangerousness unless she has a record of violent crime or violence toward her child.
  • ddjango · 8 months ago
    pretty typical for the south? in what way? last time i looked at a map, Binghamton was north of the M-D line.

    prejudice and stereotyping is moronic.
  • Sister Nancy Beth · 8 months ago
    If I'm not mistaken, the Freedom for parents to kill their children is one of the many liberties Obama has taken away from us. Socialism!
  • Butch1 · 8 months ago
    I can not tell if your statement was "tongue-in-cheek" or your true thoughts. If it was the latter, this is my response.

    No, it actually says in the Christian Bible in the Old Testament that a parent can kill their child for even sassing them back. Is this what a good Christian parent wants to teach their child? Obama had nothing to do with that and you know it. Not allowing people to kill each other in a civilized society has been a part of our laws since its founding. Why do you associate killing with socialism and Obama? That's illogical. Perhaps you should actually look up the definition of socialism before you bear false witnesses, Sister Nancy Beth. If this were a theocracy, I'm sure we would see more killings in the name of Christ. All one has to do is look to Iraq or Iran to see how gays are treated and how women are treated as well if they don't listen to their "masters." e.g. husbands. You can have organized religion, it brings nothing but unhappiness and misery.
  • SJohn · 8 months ago
    Whoa whoa whoa, Butch, I'm pretty sure she was joking. "Freedom for parents to kill their children..."? That's kind of a marker, there.

    Take a couple deep breaths.
  • Butch1 · 8 months ago
    Okay, I must need a "time-out" on this one if I can't see the intended humour.

    I will be in my wee corner with my dunce hat on for awhile. Sorry.
  • JMOHR · 8 months ago
    The Romans had a more civilized system. Under the doctrine of pater familias, it was the father's right to put to death any of his children or wife. Sounds like something the religious right would go along with.
  • Butch1 · 8 months ago
    If they only had a chance, I fear.
  • Jim Pharo · 8 months ago
    Not "just some nut." Someone's daughter, mother, sister, wife.

    I can't help but feel that society let this woman down. For 50 years the Right has been shouting about the need to vilify and humiliate the weak.

    We reap what we sew. We can and have to do better.
  • MikeinSanJo · 8 months ago
    This one came out just yesterday - the vegetarian parents who beat their 3-yr old with sticks because they thought he had demons in him from some meat he ate...

    Freedom of Religion? Tell that to the kid if he lives.
  • Older_Wiser · 8 months ago
    Religion is psychological child abuse...why should children be exposed to a half-naked man nailed to a cross and other forms of violent expression before they can even form rational thoughts? Many years ago I was dragged to evangelical "tent meetings" which terrified me as a small child and was converted to catholicism at age 8. At 15, I became a secret atheist (still a minor) with no need for any religion which has become solidified over the years.
  • tacitus · 8 months ago
    We should be thankful that there aren't more conservative Christians who follow through with the undeniable logic of their belief system.

    Think about it. She just sacrificed her son's life here on Earth because she believed (correctly, according to what conservative Christians teach) that it's far better to assure her son of eternal life in Heaven than to risk him going to Hell and suffering unending and unimaginable torture in the Lake of Fire.

    This is the pernicious truth about the doctrine of Hell. It cheapens your kids' lives (a mere four score years or so, max) to the point of worthlessness since it's not worth gambling the short lives of your children on Earth given the truly horrific consequences if your kids grow up and reject Christ and spend the next umpteen trillion years in abject anguish.
  • okojo · 8 months ago
    I tend to downplay or minimize whatever the reasons she stated, whether for Jesus, or the glorious Stalin and the mighty proletariat revolution. She was hospitalized for over a year, so her reasons are kind of redundant as much as her intent... It boils down that Florida has a problem if they can't pick up that this woman shouldn't be near a firearm. She was institutionalized, compare to the loophole that Seung-Hui Cho fell through.

    Not to bash the son, who was brutally murdered, but he also should had known to keep his mother very far away from any loaded firearm...
  • Butch1 · 8 months ago
    What was she trying to save her son from?

    Very sad.
  • Occasional Commenter · 8 months ago
    I can't help but wonder if this is a hoax. It's sick either way...
  • John Aravosis · 8 months ago
    Something about those photos did make me feel "hoax." It's funny you say that too.
  • okojo · 8 months ago
    Oh man, this is just sad and sick. She was mentally ill. She shouldn't be even near a firearm. Her son was 20. She could had easily killed a couple more.

    It kind of defeats the silly argument that everyone else with a gun would had prevented this tragedy.
  • ddjango · 8 months ago
    couldn't agree with you more
  • MVC · 8 months ago
    I read about this the other day and the article in the local paper that covered the shooting stated she was known to had a mental illness!
  • Helen Rainier · 8 months ago
    There was a recent murder/suicide in Graham, WA. A father killed his five children and then himself. Apparently, the mother had recently told the father that she was leaving and wanted a divorce. Not exactly how or why the kids were in the father's custodial care as I don't think there had been time for any child custody/visitation to be decided.
  • GoBlue · 8 months ago
    Are you sure the father had custody? Maybe the kids were with Dad for a weekend visitation.
  • GoBlue · 8 months ago
    What I meant to say: there could have been a custody or visitation order in effect if the parents were legally separated.
  • David · 8 months ago
    Oh my god. I watched that YouTube video and it really, really upset me. It isn't gory, but it is still VERY disturbing. How truly awful. What is really sad is that this mother apparently had been treated for mental illness, yet she is still able to not only own a gun, but rent ones at firing ranges. So sad.
  • GoBlue · 8 months ago
    Under Florida law she could not have bought a gun. But there is no law to stop her renting one.
  • red_dwarf · 8 months ago
    There you go. Someone rented her a gun. End of story.
  • Gridlock · 8 months ago
    This is what I find absurd about gun nuts screeching about their rights.

    The argument after every Columbine type event is "well if other people had been carrying guns too, they could have stopped the evildoer!"

    ... Well, here we are.. at a shooting range.. basically eyeball deep in guns and guess what? 2 people dead, and NOBODY COULD DO A FUCKING THING.
  • TomJoad · 8 months ago
    Not only that...look the whole premise is genuinely idotic pap from a movie someone saw.

    In REALITY, take a school shooting even. Every teacher armed and even trained. Except, someone is shooting folk, and it is total chaos...yeah, what you want in that instance is EVEN MORE GUN TOTING FOLK walking around, turning corners scared out of their wits...two teacher see each other from a distance and fire, police pull up on the scene and only know someone is shooting, here come another teacher...blam..

    That's just BRILLIANT. Police would love that scenario too I bet if some gun nut asked them "no you dipwad, we DON'T want civilians out there playing "Die Hard" and making our jobs a million times harder"...
  • Little · 8 months ago
    John, you must have been told before in you educated life that referring to a mentally ill person as "just some nut" is not just frowned upon but actually does a disservice to the mentally ill in terms of how they're viewed and treated by society as a whole.

    Just a note.
  • Carol · 8 months ago
    Please do not call mentally ill people 'nuts'. Parents do not kill their children and/or themselves if they are sane. Not the way biology/psychology/psychiatry/evolution/nuturing/etc. work. I was offended.
  • Gridlock · 8 months ago
    Pretty sure blowing her kids head off precludes any kind of politeness shown towards her "illness"

    she was a fucking psycho.
  • red_dwarf · 8 months ago
    I agree Gridlock - fucking psycho seems a bit more descriptive then "nuts". Genetic or not, she "knew" what she was doing.

    Let God have pity on her - she murdered a person who had their entire life ahead of them, in the back of the head, not knowing it was coming. The kid never had a chance.

    This is 1st degree murder, psycho or nuts or whatever.
  • Tysalpha · 8 months ago
    John, this hit me the other day when thinking about the Pennsylvania guy, and it applies to this woman perhaps: These seem to be people who feel culturally marginalized, and are dispairing about the economy / country / whatever. But what seems to be the connection is that they think they're the only ones who can fix it: The police can't protect us anymore, therefore *I* have to take care of this; *I* have to save my son. (From what? and why can't he save himself?)

    It seems like some bizarre combination of being both extremely anti-social and having a messiah complex.
  • Stop The Violence · 8 months ago
    As the others mentioned everyone there had a loaded gun in their hands, even the victim, and they stopped nothing from happening. That whole argument of 'if everyone had a gun' shit the bed with this murder suicide.
  • k8cpa · 8 months ago
    This woman was obviously mentally ill. She is one of the one's that slipped through.

    God be with her family.

    -Pat
  • jsc · 8 months ago
    John,

    I am deeply offended by your use of the term "nut". This is a person who had some form of mental illness. What you did is the same as calling a gay man a fag or a lesbian a dyke. Your take on this situation really disgusted me.

    Religion really has nothing to do with it. Even if she was not religious she would have found another reason to kill her son. And if she did not have a gun she would have found another way to kill her son.

    I have several freinds who have some type of mental illness. I am a health proxy for two to them because they at least realize there may come a time they are not able to make reasonable decision about there mental health. You think insurance companies are a problem when your have some physical issue? You have not seen anything until you deal with insurance companies and mental illness. It is a nightmare. And many who need to be in a mental facility are let out on to the streets with no support after the insurance runs out. And many can not afford the meds once insurance runs out. it is a catch 22. And their families. Don't bother asking them for assistance. The family want nothing to do with them.
  • KarenMrsLloydRichards · 8 months ago
    "Teaching moment":

    Mama's crazier than a bedbug?

    Take her out for tea at the Ritz-Carlton; DON'T go to the shooting range.
  • GoBlue · 8 months ago
    I keep thinking of how drinking and driving became socially unacceptable: enough people had lost loved ones in drunk-driving accidents that society finally reached a tipping point, Candy Lightner founded Mothers Against Drunk Driving, and the rest is history.

    I wish the same peer pressure would work with guns. Unfortunately, I suspect the NRA is counting on the fact that the people most upset by gun violence are the ones who can't speak because someone already shot them dead.
  • ShirleyGoodnessanMercy · 8 months ago
    I am very anxious to hear what she thought she was saving her son from by killing him? I pray it was not homosexuality.
  • B · 8 months ago
    The utensil she used to commit her crime is irrelevant, what matters is why she did it. no doubt mentally unhealthy, if she didnt have a gun, perhaps she would have poisoned him. or run him over. or stabbed him. guns are a vital tool engrained in our history. so are kitchen knives. she coulda stabbed him. diverting attention from the real issue to use firearms as scapegoats, is the perspective of a coward with a vendetta.
  • AreBe · 8 months ago
    Irrelevant?!?!? How likely is it she would have stabbed herself to death after killing her child? Or poisoning herself? Or running herself over? The "utensil" is entirely relevant. Guns are easy to use and if used "properly", painlessly fatal. Absent guns and bullets, what do you think the rate of citizen-citizen murder would be?
  • jim · 8 months ago
    i read earlier today that there has been more mass murders in the us in the last month than all the fatalities in iraq and afghanistan.
  • Jill · 8 months ago
    As someone who endured the high-profile murder of a friend and her family in 1971 by a father who thought he was dispatching his family to heaven, I'm always heartsick when I hear about yet another one. It isn't just about our society today; this kind of nut has been around for a long, long time. Perhaps we ought to start looking at the notion of "heaven as cop-out" and at the role Christianity as practiced in our country has in making these people think that somehow killing their family is a virtue.
  • Hugo · 8 months ago
    The Bible does not tell you to kill your family. Just because some psychos out there kill people and say it was for religious reasons, you should not rash out at religion as a whole. Religion will always be religion, but it's the people who warp it and do wrong in its name, which is sad.

    But this situation was unique due to the circumstances - the woman had mental illness.

    I think this could've been prevented if the firing range was given proper access to medical and criminal records. Apparently in the papers customers had to sign, you had to say if you had mental illness or a criminal record, yet there was no legal way of clarifying the information, due to a lack of access to resources.

    America, if you want a safer country with guns, YOU NEED TO IMPROVE YOUR LAWS, RULES AND ACCESS TO NECESSARY INFORMATION.
  • CitizenX · 8 months ago
    There used to be raw video until the networks and everyone else chose to pull it.
  • Scott · 8 months ago
    Is it too late to let the crazy bitch know she just made worm food out of her son and herself?

    Another stupid person playing God.